The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Blue Cross Denying New Treatment

Forums General Melanoma Community Blue Cross Denying New Treatment

  • Post
    Christine.P
    Participant

      I was diagnosed as stage IV just a week after the FDA approved the new Opdivo/Yervoy combination treatment. My insurance company – Bue Cross Blue Shield has denied the treatment. I was supposed to start treatment today and didn't find out about the denial until I was sitting in the waiting room. (Don't even get me started on how angry I was that they didn't call me to tel me before I got there. Have they no sense of the emotional and mental preparation it takes to get to the first treatment? And then they tell me to go home? I let them know this wasn't cool.)

      Later my doctor called me and said it could help if I called the insurnce company too. So, I called them myself today to ask wny and first they said it was because I don't meet the critera and I said, "I am stage IV and have had no previous drug treatments – how can I not meet the criteria?" 

      Then he said it was because the drugs were still experimental. I told him that wasn't true and that they had received the FDA report from my doctor to prove it. He told me we had to file an appeal and I told him my doctor had already done that. I then called my doctor back to let him know what BCBS said and he was also angry and said they would call again today. 

      Because my appeal was marked expedited, I am supposed to hear in 72 hours if I win my appeal. If I don't, I will call again and demand to speak to someone higher up the chain. 

      Has anyone fought Blue Cross and won? If so, how? 

      Thanks, again, for your support and experience.

       

    Viewing 14 reply threads
    • Replies
        arthurjedi007
        Participant

          Dunno about that company but they can be a pain. It is really up to your doc to get it approved. Calling the insurance yourself at least from my experience was very frustrating and stressful. Sorry you have to deal with the insurance company and a doc office that seems to have dropped the ball a bit. You are going through enough without this hassle. I found when the insurance gives such timelines it is really a bunch of malarky. 24 hours becomes 72 then becomes 5 to 10 business days and so on. I won by going back home and my local doc got my treatment approved.

          Artie

          arthurjedi007
          Participant

            Dunno about that company but they can be a pain. It is really up to your doc to get it approved. Calling the insurance yourself at least from my experience was very frustrating and stressful. Sorry you have to deal with the insurance company and a doc office that seems to have dropped the ball a bit. You are going through enough without this hassle. I found when the insurance gives such timelines it is really a bunch of malarky. 24 hours becomes 72 then becomes 5 to 10 business days and so on. I won by going back home and my local doc got my treatment approved.

            Artie

            arthurjedi007
            Participant

              Dunno about that company but they can be a pain. It is really up to your doc to get it approved. Calling the insurance yourself at least from my experience was very frustrating and stressful. Sorry you have to deal with the insurance company and a doc office that seems to have dropped the ball a bit. You are going through enough without this hassle. I found when the insurance gives such timelines it is really a bunch of malarky. 24 hours becomes 72 then becomes 5 to 10 business days and so on. I won by going back home and my local doc got my treatment approved.

              Artie

                tschmith
                Participant

                  Your doctor's office can call BCBS and request to have a peer to peer conversation.  Your doctor will talk to one of the doctors on their staff and discuss why it's so important for you to begin this combination treatment as soon as possible.

                  Good Luck!

                  Terrie

                  tschmith
                  Participant

                    Your doctor's office can call BCBS and request to have a peer to peer conversation.  Your doctor will talk to one of the doctors on their staff and discuss why it's so important for you to begin this combination treatment as soon as possible.

                    Good Luck!

                    Terrie

                    tschmith
                    Participant

                      Your doctor's office can call BCBS and request to have a peer to peer conversation.  Your doctor will talk to one of the doctors on their staff and discuss why it's so important for you to begin this combination treatment as soon as possible.

                      Good Luck!

                      Terrie

                    JoshF
                    Participant

                      Christine-

                      First, sorry you had to go through that. I had similar experiences with scheduling surgery and getting it approved. Just a bunch of crap….and my insurance company was telling me wrong info. Just makes my blood boil thinking of you sitting there. Artie is right, stay on your doctor….they need to provide validity of getting you treatment. Me personally, I always called too; just to keep fire burning. Sorry…hope they get it sorted out quick!

                      Josh

                      JoshF
                      Participant

                        Christine-

                        First, sorry you had to go through that. I had similar experiences with scheduling surgery and getting it approved. Just a bunch of crap….and my insurance company was telling me wrong info. Just makes my blood boil thinking of you sitting there. Artie is right, stay on your doctor….they need to provide validity of getting you treatment. Me personally, I always called too; just to keep fire burning. Sorry…hope they get it sorted out quick!

                        Josh

                        JoshF
                        Participant

                          Christine-

                          First, sorry you had to go through that. I had similar experiences with scheduling surgery and getting it approved. Just a bunch of crap….and my insurance company was telling me wrong info. Just makes my blood boil thinking of you sitting there. Artie is right, stay on your doctor….they need to provide validity of getting you treatment. Me personally, I always called too; just to keep fire burning. Sorry…hope they get it sorted out quick!

                          Josh

                          kylez
                          Participant

                            The places I'm seen at have always 100% handled the insurance approvals for me. They seem to be fully on top of it. As far as I've known I've never been denied by BC/BS. If there was a denial, it was handled behind the scenes without me ever being the wiser. So far I've had zero interaction with BC/BS (PPO) over the last 4 years. Knock on wood. 

                            kylez
                            Participant

                              The places I'm seen at have always 100% handled the insurance approvals for me. They seem to be fully on top of it. As far as I've known I've never been denied by BC/BS. If there was a denial, it was handled behind the scenes without me ever being the wiser. So far I've had zero interaction with BC/BS (PPO) over the last 4 years. Knock on wood. 

                              kylez
                              Participant

                                The places I'm seen at have always 100% handled the insurance approvals for me. They seem to be fully on top of it. As far as I've known I've never been denied by BC/BS. If there was a denial, it was handled behind the scenes without me ever being the wiser. So far I've had zero interaction with BC/BS (PPO) over the last 4 years. Knock on wood. 

                                AshleyS
                                Participant

                                  Hi Christine,

                                  I actually came on the board today to ask my own question about Blue Cross Blue Shield and one of my charges. However, I saw your post and felt I'd have some advice. 

                                  I first did chemo, as prescribed by Mayo Clinic. I then found a melanoma specialist at  M.D. Anderson. She put me on Ipi/Nivo combo (a trial when I started in March).  Since I had been on chemo and soon after switched to the trial, my doctor had to call and have it approved. We did this before I started.  Although it was a trial, Blue Cross Blue Shield still fully covered it. I'm confused as to why they will not do so for you. I agree with everyone else, get your doctor to call in. 

                                  However, we have found that it works best if we also call. We've gotten to the point where we ask for the same representative. It is so much easier than explaining your case over and over again. If you talk to someone and you feel they are competent, ask for their name and each time you call ask for them. BCBS will only give case managers to children with cancer, but they do allow you to ask for specific representative.  You can also give your doctor that specific person's name. 

                                  Also, I understand why you were frustrated with your doctor's office. They shouldn't of had you come in that day. The one thing I will say is at least they warned you. It is much easier to take care of this before you've had the treatment. 

                                  Best of luck,

                                  Ashley

                                  AshleyS
                                  Participant

                                    Hi Christine,

                                    I actually came on the board today to ask my own question about Blue Cross Blue Shield and one of my charges. However, I saw your post and felt I'd have some advice. 

                                    I first did chemo, as prescribed by Mayo Clinic. I then found a melanoma specialist at  M.D. Anderson. She put me on Ipi/Nivo combo (a trial when I started in March).  Since I had been on chemo and soon after switched to the trial, my doctor had to call and have it approved. We did this before I started.  Although it was a trial, Blue Cross Blue Shield still fully covered it. I'm confused as to why they will not do so for you. I agree with everyone else, get your doctor to call in. 

                                    However, we have found that it works best if we also call. We've gotten to the point where we ask for the same representative. It is so much easier than explaining your case over and over again. If you talk to someone and you feel they are competent, ask for their name and each time you call ask for them. BCBS will only give case managers to children with cancer, but they do allow you to ask for specific representative.  You can also give your doctor that specific person's name. 

                                    Also, I understand why you were frustrated with your doctor's office. They shouldn't of had you come in that day. The one thing I will say is at least they warned you. It is much easier to take care of this before you've had the treatment. 

                                    Best of luck,

                                    Ashley

                                    AshleyS
                                    Participant

                                      Hi Christine,

                                      I actually came on the board today to ask my own question about Blue Cross Blue Shield and one of my charges. However, I saw your post and felt I'd have some advice. 

                                      I first did chemo, as prescribed by Mayo Clinic. I then found a melanoma specialist at  M.D. Anderson. She put me on Ipi/Nivo combo (a trial when I started in March).  Since I had been on chemo and soon after switched to the trial, my doctor had to call and have it approved. We did this before I started.  Although it was a trial, Blue Cross Blue Shield still fully covered it. I'm confused as to why they will not do so for you. I agree with everyone else, get your doctor to call in. 

                                      However, we have found that it works best if we also call. We've gotten to the point where we ask for the same representative. It is so much easier than explaining your case over and over again. If you talk to someone and you feel they are competent, ask for their name and each time you call ask for them. BCBS will only give case managers to children with cancer, but they do allow you to ask for specific representative.  You can also give your doctor that specific person's name. 

                                      Also, I understand why you were frustrated with your doctor's office. They shouldn't of had you come in that day. The one thing I will say is at least they warned you. It is much easier to take care of this before you've had the treatment. 

                                      Best of luck,

                                      Ashley

                                      Gwenmorgan
                                      Participant

                                        I have no advice on BC/BS but I am interested in knowing the process your Dr's office goes through.  I am waiting for notification of denial/appeal/acceptance for Ipi/Nivo combo as well for stage IV with BC/BS as my primary- day 7 of my wait.

                                         

                                        Gwenmorgan
                                        Participant

                                          I have no advice on BC/BS but I am interested in knowing the process your Dr's office goes through.  I am waiting for notification of denial/appeal/acceptance for Ipi/Nivo combo as well for stage IV with BC/BS as my primary- day 7 of my wait.

                                           

                                          Gwenmorgan
                                          Participant

                                            I have no advice on BC/BS but I am interested in knowing the process your Dr's office goes through.  I am waiting for notification of denial/appeal/acceptance for Ipi/Nivo combo as well for stage IV with BC/BS as my primary- day 7 of my wait.

                                             

                                              Gwenmorgan
                                              Participant

                                                The BC/BS approvals went through this morning but I had nothing to do with it at all.  Lombardi took care of all communications.

                                                I am sorry I could not be more helpful.

                                                Gwenmorgan
                                                Participant

                                                  The BC/BS approvals went through this morning but I had nothing to do with it at all.  Lombardi took care of all communications.

                                                  I am sorry I could not be more helpful.

                                                  Gwenmorgan
                                                  Participant

                                                    The BC/BS approvals went through this morning but I had nothing to do with it at all.  Lombardi took care of all communications.

                                                    I am sorry I could not be more helpful.

                                                    Christine.P
                                                    Participant

                                                      Excellent news! Maybe I will also have success. ๐Ÿ™‚ Thanks for letting us know. 

                                                      Christine.P
                                                      Participant

                                                        Excellent news! Maybe I will also have success. ๐Ÿ™‚ Thanks for letting us know. 

                                                        Christine.P
                                                        Participant

                                                          Excellent news! Maybe I will also have success. ๐Ÿ™‚ Thanks for letting us know. 

                                                    Viewing 14 reply threads
                                                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                    About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                    The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                    The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide byย MRF posting policies.