The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Decisions, Decisions….

Forums General Melanoma Community Decisions, Decisions….

  • Post
    Keepingyourchinup
    Participant

      Please forgive me if this is not the place to put this but I need to say a few things and no one else seems to understand me today. So I have melanoma stage IIIA. I had a PET Scan today and it is negative; yeah, I think! I have limited options for treatment because of the stage I am, which is peglyated interferon, I almost wanted to say forget the treatment today after my results of the PET scan but then was reminded that melanoma can return and that I am at a more advanced stage, Talk about a little bit of a downer. So I searched for statistics, yes I know they are all individual…; and could really find none that say when or if it will return. I know this is a personal decision and I had originally decided to proceed with treatment until I could no longer handle it or if it changed my quality of life. I guess I am still on that path since my reminder of a more advanced stage. This post really has no meaning other than I really just want to scream right now. Ever have those feelings when others try to understand but really cant or don't? I sound like I am having a pity party, and sort of am, so do forgive the whining…. as I really just needed to vent, 

       

      Kathy 

    Viewing 8 reply threads
    • Replies
        SABKLYN
        Participant

          Hi

          weve all been and return there!  I am a 3A as well and the lack of treatment options sometimes makes you feel a little like a bench warmer in an important battle.  In my case, I turned down interferon and changed providers.  Once with my new team, i was presented the option of a VLND (right groin) or wait and watch.  I opted for the CLND and even though a lot of,the data suggests it is statistically questionable, I will never second guess the decision.  Partially because I have had very few side effects….virtually none and in my mind it was the best decision for me at that time?  So far I have been fortunate with four years of no detectable recurrence (latest scan last week).  I also enrolled in a clinical trial because,it seemed to be a reasonable step even though there is no,indication at this point that this particular regimen helped.  

          So I understand your frustration.  My suggestion is move forward with your decision; whatever it may be.  For advanced melanoma, 3a statistically is better than certain lower stages.  Hang in there.  It's a long road and statistics are on our side.  

           

            Bubbles
            Participant

              Well said, Stan.  Hang in there.  Both of you.  c

              Bubbles
              Participant

                Well said, Stan.  Hang in there.  Both of you.  c

                Bubbles
                Participant

                  Well said, Stan.  Hang in there.  Both of you.  c

                  Keepingyourchinup
                  Participant

                    Thank you for the reply. I appreciate the feedback and the encouragement. Some days are just hard BUT it could be 100 times worse so I just have to put my big girl pants on and suck it up today! 

                     

                    Kathy 

                    Keepingyourchinup
                    Participant

                      Thank you for the reply. I appreciate the feedback and the encouragement. Some days are just hard BUT it could be 100 times worse so I just have to put my big girl pants on and suck it up today! 

                       

                      Kathy 

                      Keepingyourchinup
                      Participant

                        Thank you for the reply. I appreciate the feedback and the encouragement. Some days are just hard BUT it could be 100 times worse so I just have to put my big girl pants on and suck it up today! 

                         

                        Kathy 

                      SABKLYN
                      Participant

                        Hi

                        weve all been and return there!  I am a 3A as well and the lack of treatment options sometimes makes you feel a little like a bench warmer in an important battle.  In my case, I turned down interferon and changed providers.  Once with my new team, i was presented the option of a VLND (right groin) or wait and watch.  I opted for the CLND and even though a lot of,the data suggests it is statistically questionable, I will never second guess the decision.  Partially because I have had very few side effects….virtually none and in my mind it was the best decision for me at that time?  So far I have been fortunate with four years of no detectable recurrence (latest scan last week).  I also enrolled in a clinical trial because,it seemed to be a reasonable step even though there is no,indication at this point that this particular regimen helped.  

                        So I understand your frustration.  My suggestion is move forward with your decision; whatever it may be.  For advanced melanoma, 3a statistically is better than certain lower stages.  Hang in there.  It's a long road and statistics are on our side.  

                         

                        SABKLYN
                        Participant

                          Hi

                          weve all been and return there!  I am a 3A as well and the lack of treatment options sometimes makes you feel a little like a bench warmer in an important battle.  In my case, I turned down interferon and changed providers.  Once with my new team, i was presented the option of a VLND (right groin) or wait and watch.  I opted for the CLND and even though a lot of,the data suggests it is statistically questionable, I will never second guess the decision.  Partially because I have had very few side effects….virtually none and in my mind it was the best decision for me at that time?  So far I have been fortunate with four years of no detectable recurrence (latest scan last week).  I also enrolled in a clinical trial because,it seemed to be a reasonable step even though there is no,indication at this point that this particular regimen helped.  

                          So I understand your frustration.  My suggestion is move forward with your decision; whatever it may be.  For advanced melanoma, 3a statistically is better than certain lower stages.  Hang in there.  It's a long road and statistics are on our side.  

                           

                          brewgirl68
                          Participant

                            I was dx'd with 3c, unknown primary, BRAF negative in Jan. 2015. I had CLND (right axilla) and was offered Interferon. I know from the first day that I would not do Interferon…for me personally, I just don't see enough of an up side. I have never once doubted my decision and have never looked back. 

                            There are few options for us 3's, so I'm waiting as patiently as possible for a clinical trial to come along that I qualify for. I've got my first set of post-surgery scans next month, so we'll see if that pushes me to Stage 4…not preferable by any means, but there are lots more options at 4.  

                            Interferon is a hugely personal decision. I would say that unless you are absolutely positive that Interferon is NOT for you, then you should probably at least try it. 

                            Very best wishes to you – 

                            Sheila

                              Keepingyourchinup
                              Participant

                                Thank you for sharing your story! I think I know my decision so I will at least try it. The "traditional" Interferon was a big no for me but I will try the pegylated version and see what happens. I hope your scans are clear and you find that clinical trial! It is a hunt for all of us, I think. 

                                 

                                Kathy 

                                Keepingyourchinup
                                Participant

                                  Thank you for sharing your story! I think I know my decision so I will at least try it. The "traditional" Interferon was a big no for me but I will try the pegylated version and see what happens. I hope your scans are clear and you find that clinical trial! It is a hunt for all of us, I think. 

                                   

                                  Kathy 

                                  Keepingyourchinup
                                  Participant

                                    Thank you for sharing your story! I think I know my decision so I will at least try it. The "traditional" Interferon was a big no for me but I will try the pegylated version and see what happens. I hope your scans are clear and you find that clinical trial! It is a hunt for all of us, I think. 

                                     

                                    Kathy 

                                  brewgirl68
                                  Participant

                                    I was dx'd with 3c, unknown primary, BRAF negative in Jan. 2015. I had CLND (right axilla) and was offered Interferon. I know from the first day that I would not do Interferon…for me personally, I just don't see enough of an up side. I have never once doubted my decision and have never looked back. 

                                    There are few options for us 3's, so I'm waiting as patiently as possible for a clinical trial to come along that I qualify for. I've got my first set of post-surgery scans next month, so we'll see if that pushes me to Stage 4…not preferable by any means, but there are lots more options at 4.  

                                    Interferon is a hugely personal decision. I would say that unless you are absolutely positive that Interferon is NOT for you, then you should probably at least try it. 

                                    Very best wishes to you – 

                                    Sheila

                                    brewgirl68
                                    Participant

                                      I was dx'd with 3c, unknown primary, BRAF negative in Jan. 2015. I had CLND (right axilla) and was offered Interferon. I know from the first day that I would not do Interferon…for me personally, I just don't see enough of an up side. I have never once doubted my decision and have never looked back. 

                                      There are few options for us 3's, so I'm waiting as patiently as possible for a clinical trial to come along that I qualify for. I've got my first set of post-surgery scans next month, so we'll see if that pushes me to Stage 4…not preferable by any means, but there are lots more options at 4.  

                                      Interferon is a hugely personal decision. I would say that unless you are absolutely positive that Interferon is NOT for you, then you should probably at least try it. 

                                      Very best wishes to you – 

                                      Sheila

                                      washoegal
                                      Participant

                                        Kathy,

                                        We have all had those days.  Hopefully you don't have too many.  Just remember that one of the contraindicators for interferon is depression so take care of yourself.   That being said this is a good place to Rant…we understand, where many others may not. 

                                        Let give you some good news though, I am stage 3a too.  I am now 5 years NED.  I chose just to wait and watch.  I still have all fingers and toes crossed, but I'm feeling pretty confident.

                                        Good Luck!

                                        Mary

                                          Keepingyourchinup
                                          Participant

                                            Congrats Mary! That is great news and thanks for sharing that! I start my treatment tomorrow so we shall see….. I finally put my 'big girl pants" on and am ready…. I think. By the way, I love the statement under your name; it says alot! 

                                            Kathy 

                                            Keepingyourchinup
                                            Participant

                                              Congrats Mary! That is great news and thanks for sharing that! I start my treatment tomorrow so we shall see….. I finally put my 'big girl pants" on and am ready…. I think. By the way, I love the statement under your name; it says alot! 

                                              Kathy 

                                              Keepingyourchinup
                                              Participant

                                                Congrats Mary! That is great news and thanks for sharing that! I start my treatment tomorrow so we shall see….. I finally put my 'big girl pants" on and am ready…. I think. By the way, I love the statement under your name; it says alot! 

                                                Kathy 

                                              washoegal
                                              Participant

                                                Kathy,

                                                We have all had those days.  Hopefully you don't have too many.  Just remember that one of the contraindicators for interferon is depression so take care of yourself.   That being said this is a good place to Rant…we understand, where many others may not. 

                                                Let give you some good news though, I am stage 3a too.  I am now 5 years NED.  I chose just to wait and watch.  I still have all fingers and toes crossed, but I'm feeling pretty confident.

                                                Good Luck!

                                                Mary

                                                washoegal
                                                Participant

                                                  Kathy,

                                                  We have all had those days.  Hopefully you don't have too many.  Just remember that one of the contraindicators for interferon is depression so take care of yourself.   That being said this is a good place to Rant…we understand, where many others may not. 

                                                  Let give you some good news though, I am stage 3a too.  I am now 5 years NED.  I chose just to wait and watch.  I still have all fingers and toes crossed, but I'm feeling pretty confident.

                                                  Good Luck!

                                                  Mary

                                              Viewing 8 reply threads
                                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                              About the MRF Patient Forum

                                              The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                              The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                              Popular Topics