The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Surf Rower

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Replies
      Surf Rower
      Participant

        correction, they did an EKG, not an echocardiogram.  Also chest X-ray and blood work.

        Surf Rower
        Participant

          correction, they did an EKG, not an echocardiogram.  Also chest X-ray and blood work.

          Surf Rower
          Participant

            correction, they did an EKG, not an echocardiogram.  Also chest X-ray and blood work.

            Surf Rower
            Participant

              SORRY-  I made a mistake in that last post – the first excision scar is only an inch long.   It was the _second_ one, drawn on my arm with a marker, that will be 2.5".  Nevertheless, all this general anesthesia business is making me think they are doing a major surgery.

               

              Surf Rower
              Participant

                SORRY-  I made a mistake in that last post – the first excision scar is only an inch long.   It was the _second_ one, drawn on my arm with a marker, that will be 2.5".  Nevertheless, all this general anesthesia business is making me think they are doing a major surgery.

                 

                Surf Rower
                Participant

                  SORRY-  I made a mistake in that last post – the first excision scar is only an inch long.   It was the _second_ one, drawn on my arm with a marker, that will be 2.5".  Nevertheless, all this general anesthesia business is making me think they are doing a major surgery.

                   

                  Surf Rower
                  Participant

                    Returning to my thread here because now I"m more confused than ever, due to the way the cancer center is treating this (overkill). My original excision scar is 2.5 inches, same as yours, so I'm not sure why the second doctor looked at and said it wasn't long enough. Today I had EKG, blood work, and chest x-ray and several lengthy interviews in prep for the re-excision. They tell me to do all  kinds of crazy cleansing for two days before, and I will not be able to work the day after the surgery and should prepare to be at the hospital 5 hours and have someone stay with me 24 hours. This seems like way too big a deal for this tiny 0.2 mm thing. So just now I called the plastic surgeon who did the first excision to ask his opinion. He thinks they are doing overkill and he would be happy to take me sooner and do it with local anesthetic as before. He thinks there was no issue with the tissue being oriented one way or the other because the speck of mel remaining would have been where the incision line was, in the middle.  Now (he says) the speck is in the center where it is stitched. Does that mean he didn't go _deep_ enough? I'm having trouble picture this exactly. It was the football shape.  I am seeing the original dermatologist on Tuesday, the guy who referred me to the plastic surgeon, so I can also ask him.  Sorry guys, I feel like 1a problems are like "first world problems" when so many of you have much more serious challenges, but it is confusing being new to cancer.  Thank you all for any additional thoughts.  – Surf

                    Surf Rower
                    Participant

                      Returning to my thread here because now I"m more confused than ever, due to the way the cancer center is treating this (overkill). My original excision scar is 2.5 inches, same as yours, so I'm not sure why the second doctor looked at and said it wasn't long enough. Today I had EKG, blood work, and chest x-ray and several lengthy interviews in prep for the re-excision. They tell me to do all  kinds of crazy cleansing for two days before, and I will not be able to work the day after the surgery and should prepare to be at the hospital 5 hours and have someone stay with me 24 hours. This seems like way too big a deal for this tiny 0.2 mm thing. So just now I called the plastic surgeon who did the first excision to ask his opinion. He thinks they are doing overkill and he would be happy to take me sooner and do it with local anesthetic as before. He thinks there was no issue with the tissue being oriented one way or the other because the speck of mel remaining would have been where the incision line was, in the middle.  Now (he says) the speck is in the center where it is stitched. Does that mean he didn't go _deep_ enough? I'm having trouble picture this exactly. It was the football shape.  I am seeing the original dermatologist on Tuesday, the guy who referred me to the plastic surgeon, so I can also ask him.  Sorry guys, I feel like 1a problems are like "first world problems" when so many of you have much more serious challenges, but it is confusing being new to cancer.  Thank you all for any additional thoughts.  – Surf

                      Surf Rower
                      Participant

                        Returning to my thread here because now I"m more confused than ever, due to the way the cancer center is treating this (overkill). My original excision scar is 2.5 inches, same as yours, so I'm not sure why the second doctor looked at and said it wasn't long enough. Today I had EKG, blood work, and chest x-ray and several lengthy interviews in prep for the re-excision. They tell me to do all  kinds of crazy cleansing for two days before, and I will not be able to work the day after the surgery and should prepare to be at the hospital 5 hours and have someone stay with me 24 hours. This seems like way too big a deal for this tiny 0.2 mm thing. So just now I called the plastic surgeon who did the first excision to ask his opinion. He thinks they are doing overkill and he would be happy to take me sooner and do it with local anesthetic as before. He thinks there was no issue with the tissue being oriented one way or the other because the speck of mel remaining would have been where the incision line was, in the middle.  Now (he says) the speck is in the center where it is stitched. Does that mean he didn't go _deep_ enough? I'm having trouble picture this exactly. It was the football shape.  I am seeing the original dermatologist on Tuesday, the guy who referred me to the plastic surgeon, so I can also ask him.  Sorry guys, I feel like 1a problems are like "first world problems" when so many of you have much more serious challenges, but it is confusing being new to cancer.  Thank you all for any additional thoughts.  – Surf

                        Surf Rower
                        Participant

                          OK, thanks for the backup guys – I am going back for the WLE.  The doc called me back within 5 hours (yay doc) and we talked it all over. He doesn't take chances. I think he wants to see the slide because it had not been marked which edge had melanocytes. Possibly the excision could be smaller if they can tell which side.

                          Surf Rower
                          Participant

                            OK, thanks for the backup guys – I am going back for the WLE.  The doc called me back within 5 hours (yay doc) and we talked it all over. He doesn't take chances. I think he wants to see the slide because it had not been marked which edge had melanocytes. Possibly the excision could be smaller if they can tell which side.

                            Surf Rower
                            Participant

                              OK, thanks for the backup guys – I am going back for the WLE.  The doc called me back within 5 hours (yay doc) and we talked it all over. He doesn't take chances. I think he wants to see the slide because it had not been marked which edge had melanocytes. Possibly the excision could be smaller if they can tell which side.

                              Surf Rower
                              Participant

                                Agree with Ann. I was diagnosed 1A two weeks ago and the derm referred me to a plastic surgeon to do the wide excision. He did a beautiful job and the scar is pretty but he didn't get all the melanoma! Now I have to have it done wider, and extra wide because of the first scar. I switched to an oncological surgeon at a cancer center. Kind of bummed my arm will have a shark bite out of it, but I'm sure this guy will get it all.

                                Surf Rower
                                Participant

                                  Agree with Ann. I was diagnosed 1A two weeks ago and the derm referred me to a plastic surgeon to do the wide excision. He did a beautiful job and the scar is pretty but he didn't get all the melanoma! Now I have to have it done wider, and extra wide because of the first scar. I switched to an oncological surgeon at a cancer center. Kind of bummed my arm will have a shark bite out of it, but I'm sure this guy will get it all.

                                  Surf Rower
                                  Participant

                                    Agree with Ann. I was diagnosed 1A two weeks ago and the derm referred me to a plastic surgeon to do the wide excision. He did a beautiful job and the scar is pretty but he didn't get all the melanoma! Now I have to have it done wider, and extra wide because of the first scar. I switched to an oncological surgeon at a cancer center. Kind of bummed my arm will have a shark bite out of it, but I'm sure this guy will get it all.

                                Viewing 1 reply thread
                                About the MRF Patient Forum

                                The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                Popular Topics